NEWS
Japan Sports Council reveals cost of abandoning Zaha Hadid's Tokyo stadium design
POSTED 30 Aug 2016 . BY Kim Megson
Zaha Hadid Architects were dropped from the Olympic Stadium project just days after having their design approved Credit: Zaha Hadid Architects
Credit: Zaha Hadid Architects
We were so happy to get that project, it was a well deserved win and we were looking forward to 2020. That was pulled away from us. We found the whole experience incredibly distressing.
– Patrik Schumacher, director at Zaha Hadid Architects
The body in charge of organising Tokyo’s Olympic Games has admitted its decision to cancel Zaha Hadid Architects’ (ZHA) National Olympic Stadium design in favour of a cheaper alternative has already cost it ¥68.6bn (US$650.6m, €582.4m, £497m) in compensation payouts.

According to media reports in the country, the Japan Sports Council (JSC) announced it has already earmarked the sum – ¥600m US$5.8m, €5.2m, £4.4m) higher than the amount estimated by the sports ministry in August 2015 – to cancel the original construction project.

The Tokyo Reporter and ANN News claim the unrecoverable figure includes a ¥1.39bn (US$13.5m, €12.1m, £10.3m) payment to ZHA to cover stadium design fees and the cost of closing their Tokyo office. Four other companies, including Japanese architects Nikken Sekkei, have received ¥3.8bn (US$37.1m, €33.2m, £28.3m) in design costs, while engineering firms Taisei Corp and Takenaka Corp have received ¥777m (US$7.6m, €6.8m, £5.8m).

It remains to be seen whether the payment will put an end to the acrimonious saga, which began when ZHA were dropped from the Olympic Stadium project, despite winning an international design competition. Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said the cost of the stadium – which had been criticised by Japanese architects including Toyo Ito and Fumihiko Maki – had “just ballooned too much” after almost doubling to US$2bn (€1.79bn, £1.52bn).

A succession of skirmishes followed, with ZHA issuing a robust defence of their design, blaming the cost increases on Japan's overheated construction market and the tendering process for the building, in which contractors were appointed before they submitted cost estimates.

"Our warning was not heeded that selecting contractors too early in a heated construction market and without sufficient competition would lead to an overly high estimate of the cost of construction,” they said.

In December 2015, Kengo Kuma was selected to design the stadium within a budget of ¥155bn (US$1.5bn, €1.3bn, £1.1bn). That decision also prompted anger, with ZHA saying his design shared similarities with theirs – an accusation he has flatly denied.

Summarising the saga in an interview with Sports Management's sister publicationCLAD, ZHA director Patrik Schumacher said: “It was the biggest setback ever. I found it absolutely shocking and Zaha was devastated. We were so happy to get that project, it was a well deserved win and we were looking forward to 2020. That was pulled away from us. We found the whole experience incredibly distressing.

“It was such a humiliation. The loss of two years intense, passionate work, not to mention the guys flying to Japan all of the time. You can only do that if you have that reward in sight.

“Everyone was depressed and demoralised, and there was also the potential shock to our reputation – the perception that this was due to our obstinacy or outrageous extravagance in terms of the design. None of this was true, but the suspicion lingers on in the minds of clients. That's why we made a PR effort to try to explain what happened and how conscientious we'd been in the process, signalling all the way through until the final decision that we were totally willing to do anything.”

Kuma told CLAD that communication problems were to blame for the controversy. “I think it’s a problem in Japan,” he said. “For foreign architects to work in Japan is not easy because the system is totally different and the language barrier exists between Japanese and the foreigners. Zaha was very much frustrated with that kind of miscommunication and I understand that difficulty.”

Construction on Kuma’s Olympic Stadium is set to begin in the coming months and is due to be completed by November 2019.

It will host the opening and closing ceremonies for the 2020 Games, as well as athletics, rugby and football fixtures.
RELATED STORIES
  Kengo Kuma hits back in Tokyo 2020 stadium row


The architect developing Japan’s National Stadium for the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games has publicly refuted claims his studio have copied from an earlier design submitted by Zaha Hadid Architects.
  Zaha Hadid refuses to hand over copyright to Tokyo 2020 stadium design


Zaha Hadid Architects (ZHA) have claimed the Japan Sports Council are withholding payment for the studio’s design for the Japan National Stadium in Tokyo unless the architects give up the copyright to the designs and sign a confidentiality clause.
  Zaha Hadid cries foul as Tokyo 2020 stadium design is chosen


Japanese architects Kengo Kuma have been selected to design the 80,000 capacity stadium which will be the centrepiece of the 2020 Olympics in Tokyo.
  Japan Sports Council unveils Olympic Stadium designs


Two stadium designs for the 2020 Tokyo Olympics have been revealed by the Japanese Sports Council.
 


CONTACT US

Leisure Media
Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385

©Cybertrek 2024

ABOUT LEISURE MEDIA
LEISURE MEDIA MAGAZINES
LEISURE MEDIA HANDBOOKS
LEISURE MEDIA WEBSITES
LEISURE MEDIA PRODUCT SEARCH
PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
Leisure Management - Japan Sports Council reveals cost of abandoning Zaha Hadid's Tokyo stadium design...
20 May 2024 Leisure Management: daily news and jobs
 
 
HOME
JOBS
NEWS
FEATURES
PRODUCTS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION
PRINT SUBSCRIPTION
ADVERTISE
CONTACT US
Sign up for FREE ezine
Latest news

30 Aug 2016

Japan Sports Council reveals cost of abandoning Zaha Hadid's Tokyo stadium design
BY Kim Megson

Zaha Hadid Architects were dropped from the Olympic Stadium project just days after having their design approved

Zaha Hadid Architects were dropped from the Olympic Stadium project just days after having their design approved
photo: Zaha Hadid Architects

The body in charge of organising Tokyo’s Olympic Games has admitted its decision to cancel Zaha Hadid Architects’ (ZHA) National Olympic Stadium design in favour of a cheaper alternative has already cost it ¥68.6bn (US$650.6m, €582.4m, £497m) in compensation payouts.

According to media reports in the country, the Japan Sports Council (JSC) announced it has already earmarked the sum – ¥600m US$5.8m, €5.2m, £4.4m) higher than the amount estimated by the sports ministry in August 2015 – to cancel the original construction project.

The Tokyo Reporter and ANN News claim the unrecoverable figure includes a ¥1.39bn (US$13.5m, €12.1m, £10.3m) payment to ZHA to cover stadium design fees and the cost of closing their Tokyo office. Four other companies, including Japanese architects Nikken Sekkei, have received ¥3.8bn (US$37.1m, €33.2m, £28.3m) in design costs, while engineering firms Taisei Corp and Takenaka Corp have received ¥777m (US$7.6m, €6.8m, £5.8m).

It remains to be seen whether the payment will put an end to the acrimonious saga, which began when ZHA were dropped from the Olympic Stadium project, despite winning an international design competition. Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said the cost of the stadium – which had been criticised by Japanese architects including Toyo Ito and Fumihiko Maki – had “just ballooned too much” after almost doubling to US$2bn (€1.79bn, £1.52bn).

A succession of skirmishes followed, with ZHA issuing a robust defence of their design, blaming the cost increases on Japan's overheated construction market and the tendering process for the building, in which contractors were appointed before they submitted cost estimates.

"Our warning was not heeded that selecting contractors too early in a heated construction market and without sufficient competition would lead to an overly high estimate of the cost of construction,” they said.

In December 2015, Kengo Kuma was selected to design the stadium within a budget of ¥155bn (US$1.5bn, €1.3bn, £1.1bn). That decision also prompted anger, with ZHA saying his design shared similarities with theirs – an accusation he has flatly denied.

Summarising the saga in an interview with Sports Management's sister publicationCLAD, ZHA director Patrik Schumacher said: “It was the biggest setback ever. I found it absolutely shocking and Zaha was devastated. We were so happy to get that project, it was a well deserved win and we were looking forward to 2020. That was pulled away from us. We found the whole experience incredibly distressing.

“It was such a humiliation. The loss of two years intense, passionate work, not to mention the guys flying to Japan all of the time. You can only do that if you have that reward in sight.

“Everyone was depressed and demoralised, and there was also the potential shock to our reputation – the perception that this was due to our obstinacy or outrageous extravagance in terms of the design. None of this was true, but the suspicion lingers on in the minds of clients. That's why we made a PR effort to try to explain what happened and how conscientious we'd been in the process, signalling all the way through until the final decision that we were totally willing to do anything.”

Kuma told CLAD that communication problems were to blame for the controversy. “I think it’s a problem in Japan,” he said. “For foreign architects to work in Japan is not easy because the system is totally different and the language barrier exists between Japanese and the foreigners. Zaha was very much frustrated with that kind of miscommunication and I understand that difficulty.”

Construction on Kuma’s Olympic Stadium is set to begin in the coming months and is due to be completed by November 2019.

It will host the opening and closing ceremonies for the 2020 Games, as well as athletics, rugby and football fixtures.



Connect with
Leisure Management
Magazine:
View issue contents
Sign up:
Instant Alerts/zines

Print edition
 

News headlines
QC New York to unveil 15,000sq ft multimillion-dollar expansion in July
QC New York to unveil 15,000sq ft multimillion-dollar expansion in July   20 May 2024

QC New York, a luxury Italian day spa on Governors Island, will expand its offering this July by adding an extra 15,000sq ft of space. This new area .... more>>
1Rebel plans expansion following cash injection from Imbiba
1Rebel plans expansion following cash injection from Imbiba   20 May 2024

Leisure, lifestyle, wellness and entertainment growth investor, Imbiba, has invested in boutique gym brand, 1Rebel's holding company, One Rebel Ltd, .... more>>
PILAT3S to debut in ClubSportive, Amsterdam
PILAT3S to debut in ClubSportive, Amsterdam   20 May 2024

Urban Gym Group will launch PILAT3S at ClubSportive in Amsterdam next month, to create a boutique-in-gym experience. PILAT3S is the newly-launched .... more>>
Cedric Bryant is the new CEO at The American Council on Exercise
Cedric Bryant is the new CEO at The American Council on Exercise   20 May 2024

The American Council on Exercise has appointed Dr Cedric Bryant as its new CEO. Bryant takes up the new position on 1 July, following on from .... more>>
Wellness real estate market booming – forecast to reach $913bn by 2028, reports GWI
Wellness real estate market booming – forecast to reach $913bn by 2028, reports GWI   17 May 2024

The Global Wellness Institute (GWI) has released promising new research on the wellness real estate market at its third-annual Wellness Real Estate & .... more>>
Banyan Group appoints Paul Hawco to spearhead wellness strategy
Banyan Group appoints Paul Hawco to spearhead wellness strategy   14 May 2024

Paul Hawco, a seasoned figure in the international wellness industry, has assumed the role of executive director – integrated wellbeing at .... more>>
Company profile


We Work Well Inc

We Work Well is a global premier hosted buyer event company, connecting high-level executives from leading suppliers with pre-selected highly qualified buyers in the wellness and hospitality industries.

View full profile>>

Catalogue gallery


Featured Supplier

Red Raion expands global presence with new Riyadh office

Red Raion expands global presence with new Riyadh office

Red Raion, the CGI studio for media-based attractions, has announced the opening of its new office in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. More>>




in this issue

• Virgin gets right to wipe out rent arrears
• Fitness industry mourns passing of Jan Spaticchia
• STA offers mindfulness resources



Latest jobs

Jobs Search



Fitness Instructor
Salary: £23,144 to £25,138pa
Location: Moulsecoomb, Brighton and Hove, Brighton, UK
Company: University of Brighton
Duty Manager
Salary: Competitive
Location: Clevedon
Company: Everyone Active
Swim Teacher
Salary: Competitive
Location: Bristol
Company: Everyone Active
Diary dates
Powered by leisurediary.com

18-22 May 2024

Eco Resort Network

The Ravenala Attitude Hotel, Mauritius







Published by Leisure Media Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385 | Contact us | About us | © Cybertrek Ltd