NEWS
California gyms sue state over COVID-19 closures
POSTED 22 Sep 2020 . BY Tom Walker
In some areas in California, fitness facilities are allowed to operate at just 10 per cent of capacity Credit: Shutterstock.com/Ajan Alen
Health club and gyms operators in California are suing state governor Gavin Newsom in an attempt to reopen the state’s fitness facilities.

The California Fitness Alliance (CFA) filed the lawsuit in response to Newsom’s measures to curb the spread of COVID-19 – which CFA says "unfairly targets" the fitness industry.

Gyms and health clubs were first ordered to close their doors in March. After a relaxing of lockdown measures in June, they were then ordered to re-close their doors in mid-July, just weeks after being allowed to open.

Under current rules, fitness centres are allowed to reopen indoors at 10 per cent of capacity in areas where infections drop from "widespread to substantial". In areas with minimal infections, gyms can reopen indoors at 50 per cent capacity. In areas where the virus is deemed "widespread", gyms remain closed.

In the lawsuit, filed at Los Angeles County Superior Court, CFA says that the governor is wrong to force gyms to close without providing evidence that they contribute to virus outbreaks.

"When the pandemic began, CFA members focused on being part of the solution," said Francesca Schuler, CFA founding partner and CEO of In-Shape Health Clubs.

"We created strict guidelines to ensure public safety when exercising indoors, so Californians could receive the health benefits associated with exercise and help expand the fight against COVID-19. When the state briefly reopened, these protocols worked.

“Despite repeated requests for information, California has not shared any data about the sources of outbreaks in the state, but a CFA study revealed that of the more than 5.5 million members who checked into 285 fitness centers between June 12 and July 13, only 0.002 percent of those members tested positive for COVID-19."

Scott J. Street, a lawyer representing CFA, added: “CFA is taking this action reluctantly.

"Its members not only complied with the initial eight-week shutdown but many were proactive in shutting down prior to the statewide stay-at-home order in March, as a demonstration of their commitment to the health of their communities.

“Since then, CFA has worked with the Governor’s Office and state health officials to detail how indoor fitness activities can safely reopen and strengthen the statewide effort to help people maintain their health and well-being during the pandemic.

"Unfortunately, the indefinite extension of a virtual statewide shutdown and unfounded rules restricting access to fitness centers are jeopardizing the health and well-being of millions of Californians who need a safe and secure place to exercise. It is also having a devastating impact on the many thousands who serve in fitness, most of whom got into the industry because they believe in helping people lead healthier lives.”

CFA was formed in March with the aim of becoming the "united voice of all fitness professionals in California". To find out more, click here.
RELATED STORIES
  Boutiques back to 91 per cent of pre-COVID levels in some world regions


Boutique gym attendance and class bookings in some world regions have bounced back to around 91 per cent of pre-COVID levels.
  US gyms are beating COVID-19


A study of gym visit data from the US suggests that health clubs and fitness facilities are not contributing to the spread of COVID-19.
  Phillip Mills: Gyms are a cornerstone of global recovery from COVID-19


Gyms and health clubs are a cornerstone of the global recovery from COVID-19 – and should be given the necessary backing by governments, according to Phillip Mills, founder and executive director of Les Mills.
 


CONTACT US

Leisure Media
Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385

©Cybertrek 2026

ABOUT LEISURE MEDIA
LEISURE MEDIA MAGAZINES
LEISURE MEDIA HANDBOOKS
LEISURE MEDIA WEBSITES
LEISURE MEDIA PRODUCT SEARCH
PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
Leisure Management - California gyms sue state over COVID-19 closures...
15 Jun 2026 Leisure Management: daily news and jobs
 
 
HOME
JOBS
NEWS
FEATURES
PRODUCTS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION
PRINT SUBSCRIPTION
ADVERTISE
CONTACT US
Sign up for FREE ezine
Latest news

22 Sep 2020

California gyms sue state over COVID-19 closures
BY Tom Walker

In some areas in California, fitness facilities are allowed to operate at just 10 per cent of capacity

In some areas in California, fitness facilities are allowed to operate at just 10 per cent of capacity
photo: Shutterstock.com/Ajan Alen

Health club and gyms operators in California are suing state governor Gavin Newsom in an attempt to reopen the state’s fitness facilities.

The California Fitness Alliance (CFA) filed the lawsuit in response to Newsom’s measures to curb the spread of COVID-19 – which CFA says "unfairly targets" the fitness industry.

Gyms and health clubs were first ordered to close their doors in March. After a relaxing of lockdown measures in June, they were then ordered to re-close their doors in mid-July, just weeks after being allowed to open.

Under current rules, fitness centres are allowed to reopen indoors at 10 per cent of capacity in areas where infections drop from "widespread to substantial". In areas with minimal infections, gyms can reopen indoors at 50 per cent capacity. In areas where the virus is deemed "widespread", gyms remain closed.

In the lawsuit, filed at Los Angeles County Superior Court, CFA says that the governor is wrong to force gyms to close without providing evidence that they contribute to virus outbreaks.

"When the pandemic began, CFA members focused on being part of the solution," said Francesca Schuler, CFA founding partner and CEO of In-Shape Health Clubs.

"We created strict guidelines to ensure public safety when exercising indoors, so Californians could receive the health benefits associated with exercise and help expand the fight against COVID-19. When the state briefly reopened, these protocols worked.

“Despite repeated requests for information, California has not shared any data about the sources of outbreaks in the state, but a CFA study revealed that of the more than 5.5 million members who checked into 285 fitness centers between June 12 and July 13, only 0.002 percent of those members tested positive for COVID-19."

Scott J. Street, a lawyer representing CFA, added: “CFA is taking this action reluctantly.

"Its members not only complied with the initial eight-week shutdown but many were proactive in shutting down prior to the statewide stay-at-home order in March, as a demonstration of their commitment to the health of their communities.

“Since then, CFA has worked with the Governor’s Office and state health officials to detail how indoor fitness activities can safely reopen and strengthen the statewide effort to help people maintain their health and well-being during the pandemic.

"Unfortunately, the indefinite extension of a virtual statewide shutdown and unfounded rules restricting access to fitness centers are jeopardizing the health and well-being of millions of Californians who need a safe and secure place to exercise. It is also having a devastating impact on the many thousands who serve in fitness, most of whom got into the industry because they believe in helping people lead healthier lives.”

CFA was formed in March with the aim of becoming the "united voice of all fitness professionals in California". To find out more, click here.



Connect with
Leisure Management
Magazine:
View issue contents
Sign up:
Instant Alerts/zines

Print edition
 

News headlines
Les Mills calls on the industry to support UNICEF
Les Mills calls on the industry to support UNICEF   12 Jun 2026

Global group exercise specialist, Les Mills, is inviting operators to sign up to its Workout for the World event on 20 June, in support of .... more>>

Belgin Aksoy prepares to mark 15 years of Global Wellness Day on Saturday 13 June
Belgin Aksoy prepares to mark 15 years of Global Wellness Day on Saturday 13 June   12 Jun 2026

Global Wellness Day (GWD) will mark its 15th anniversary on Saturday 13 June 2026, with the theme: #JoyMagenta – a celebration of the healing .... more>>

HUM2N opens longevity clinic at Six Senses London
HUM2N opens longevity clinic at Six Senses London   12 Jun 2026

Global luxury hospitality brand, Six Senses, has partnered with longevity healthcare provider, HUM2N, to launch a clinic at Six Senses London, at .... more>>

Mayrlife opens first hotel day clinic in partnership with Rosewood Vienna
Mayrlife opens first hotel day clinic in partnership with Rosewood Vienna   11 Jun 2026

As part of its first hotel partnership, Mayrlife – the medical health resort company known for its site in Altaussee, Austria – has launched a day .... more>>

KX Chelsea invests £15 million to upgrade its wellness offering
KX Chelsea invests £15 million to upgrade its wellness offering   10 Jun 2026

Premium London health club, KX Chelsea, is gearing up to unveil its most significant redevelopment since its launch in 2002.

....
more>>
Researchers identify a drug which reduces muscle loss when using GLP-1 medications
Researchers identify a drug which reduces muscle loss when using GLP-1 medications   10 Jun 2026

Researchers in the US have identified an antibody which could greatly reduce the loss of lean muscle mass in people who are taking weight-loss .... more>>

Company profile


Painting With Light

By combining lighting, video, scenic and architectural elements, sound and special effects we tell stories, create emotion and give your audience an experience that they will always remember.

View full profile>>

Catalogue gallery


Featured Supplier

Glow beyond protection: meet Comfort Zone Hydramemory Hybrid Glow SPF 30

Glow beyond protection: meet Comfort Zone Hydramemory Hybrid Glow SPF 30

Sun protection is no longer just about shielding the skin – it's about enhancing it. More>>




in this issue

• Virgin gets right to wipe out rent arrears
• Fitness industry mourns passing of Jan Spaticchia
• STA offers mindfulness resources



Latest jobs

Jobs Search



Community Activator Coach Apprentice
Salary: 16,686
Location: Stowmarket, Suffolk
Company: Everyone Active
Membership Advisor
Salary: Competitive salary plus commission & benefits
Location: Market Rasen
Company: Everyone Active
Customer Service Advisor
Salary: Competitive
Location: Market Rasen
Company: Everyone Active
Diary dates
Powered by leisurediary.com

15-18 Jun 2026

HLTH Europe

RAI Convention Centre, Amsterdam, Netherlands







Published by Leisure Media Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385 | Contact us | About us | © Cybertrek Ltd