NEWS
BMJ research: benefits of exercise referral schemes 'not as large as hoped'
POSTED 02 Dec 2019 . BY Tom Walker
The study drew on data from 23,731 active participants in 13 different exercise referral schemes Credit: Shutterstock
The improvements in health and wellbeing associated with exercise referral schemes aren’t as large as hoped, according to a new study.

A team of researchers looked at data from 23,731 active participants in 13 different exercise referral schemes in the UK, lasting between six weeks and three months, which had been entered into the dedicated National Referral Database.

They looked at measurements recorded at the beginning and end of the schemes in weight (BMI), blood pressure, resting heart rate – as well as scores on internationally-validated mental health, wellbeing, quality of life and exercise confidence scales.

An analysis of the data, Published in the Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, revealed significant improvements in most of the included measures – the exceptions being resting heart rate (a known risk factor for death from cardiovascular disease) and diastolic blood pressure (the bottom number in a blood pressure reading, signifying the pressure in the arteries between heartbeats).

But when these figures were compared with thresholds for clinical “meaningfulness”, the changes didn’t reach these thresholds. In other words, the size of the changes was so small that it made rendering their impact unclear.

The study also found that the referral schemes varied considerably in length and content, as did the characteristics of the participants, so it’s not clear which combination of activities and length of scheme might be most effective, or for whom.

"This is an observational study, and as such, can’t establish cause," the study reads.

"And there were considerable differences in outcomes between individual schemes.

"Currently there is a lack of agreement of what constitutes ‘impact’ with respect to the evaluation of exercise referral schemes and the evidence presented here from one of the largest databases of them does little to support the use of them."

The researchers also suggest that, given how widely used the exercise referrals are, a more critical approach is needed.

“These findings support the need to consider exercise referral schemes, particularly their implementation, more critically, using real world data to understand how best to maximise their potential, particularly considering the known benefits of exercise and the research of [exercise referral schemes] across the UK,” the study reads in its conclusion.

Click here to download and read the full study, titled Effect of exercise referral schemes upon health and well-being: initial observational insights using individual patient data meta-analysis from the National Referral Database.

The Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health is published by the BMJ Group, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the British Medical Association.
RELATED STORIES
Study: any amount of running offers 'substantial improvements' to health


Any amount of regular running can dramatically reduce the risk of death, according to a study published in the British Medical Journal.
HIIT more effective for weight loss than lengthy, moderate forms of exercise


High intensity interval training (HIIT) is a more effective way to lose weight than longer, more moderate forms of exercise.
BMJ urges public health focus on childhood physical activity


Public health policy should be focused on preventing the decline of physical activity during childhood, not when individuals reach adolescence, according to British Medical Journal (BMJ) research.
Government must reverse 12 years of obesity inertia, says wellness champion


The government must take bold steps to make inroads in tackling Britain’s burgeoning childhood obesity and inactivity problem, which has ballooned after more than a decade of policy inertia.
 


CONTACT US

Leisure Media, Portmill House, Portmill Lane,
Hitchin, Hertfordshire SG5 1DJ Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385

©Cybertrek 2020

ABOUT LEISURE MEDIA
LEISURE MEDIA MAGAZINES
LEISURE MEDIA HANDBOOKS
LEISURE MEDIA WEBSITES
LEISURE MEDIA PRODUCT SEARCH
PRINT SUBSCRIPTIONS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
Leisure Management - BMJ research: benefits of exercise referral schemes 'not as large as hoped'...
13 Aug 2020 Leisure Management: daily news and jobs
 
 
HOME
JOBS
NEWS
FEATURES
PRODUCTS
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION
PRINT SUBSCRIPTION
ADVERTISE
CONTACT US
Sign up for FREE ezine
Latest news

02 Dec 2019

BMJ research: benefits of exercise referral schemes 'not as large as hoped'
BY Tom Walker

The study drew on data from 23,731 active participants in 13 different exercise referral schemes

The study drew on data from 23,731 active participants in 13 different exercise referral schemes
photo: Shutterstock

The improvements in health and wellbeing associated with exercise referral schemes aren’t as large as hoped, according to a new study.

A team of researchers looked at data from 23,731 active participants in 13 different exercise referral schemes in the UK, lasting between six weeks and three months, which had been entered into the dedicated National Referral Database.

They looked at measurements recorded at the beginning and end of the schemes in weight (BMI), blood pressure, resting heart rate – as well as scores on internationally-validated mental health, wellbeing, quality of life and exercise confidence scales.

An analysis of the data, Published in the Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, revealed significant improvements in most of the included measures – the exceptions being resting heart rate (a known risk factor for death from cardiovascular disease) and diastolic blood pressure (the bottom number in a blood pressure reading, signifying the pressure in the arteries between heartbeats).

But when these figures were compared with thresholds for clinical “meaningfulness”, the changes didn’t reach these thresholds. In other words, the size of the changes was so small that it made rendering their impact unclear.

The study also found that the referral schemes varied considerably in length and content, as did the characteristics of the participants, so it’s not clear which combination of activities and length of scheme might be most effective, or for whom.

"This is an observational study, and as such, can’t establish cause," the study reads.

"And there were considerable differences in outcomes between individual schemes.

"Currently there is a lack of agreement of what constitutes ‘impact’ with respect to the evaluation of exercise referral schemes and the evidence presented here from one of the largest databases of them does little to support the use of them."

The researchers also suggest that, given how widely used the exercise referrals are, a more critical approach is needed.

“These findings support the need to consider exercise referral schemes, particularly their implementation, more critically, using real world data to understand how best to maximise their potential, particularly considering the known benefits of exercise and the research of [exercise referral schemes] across the UK,” the study reads in its conclusion.

Click here to download and read the full study, titled Effect of exercise referral schemes upon health and well-being: initial observational insights using individual patient data meta-analysis from the National Referral Database.

The Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health is published by the BMJ Group, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the British Medical Association.



Connect with
Leisure Management
Magazine:
View issue contents
Sign up:
Instant Alerts/zines

Print edition
 

News headlines
Property Bounceback Grant 'would save 375,000 jobs' across physical activity, hospitality and retail sectors
Property Bounceback Grant 'would save 375,000 jobs' across physical activity, hospitality and retail sectors   12 Aug 2020

A government investment of £1.75bn – to pay 50 per cent of rents across the retail, hospitality and leisure sectors for six months – would save .... more>>
Birmingham 2022 'de-risks' Commonwealth Games – scraps plans for £520m athletes' village
Birmingham 2022 'de-risks' Commonwealth Games – scraps plans for £520m athletes' village   12 Aug 2020

The organising committee of the Birmingham 2022 Commonwealth Games have shelved plans to create an athletes' village in the Perry Barr area of the .... more>>
GWI Q&A: Canyon Ranch’s Nicola Finley talks inequality and the black community’s concept of wellness
GWI Q&A: Canyon Ranch’s Nicola Finley talks inequality and the black community’s concept of wellness   12 Aug 2020

Dr Nicola Finley, doctor and integrative medicine practitioner at Canyon Ranch, Tucson, spoke with GWI’s VP of research and forecasting, Beth .... more>>
Spanish gyms win legal fight to reopen after second lockdown
Spanish gyms win legal fight to reopen after second lockdown   11 Aug 2020

Health clubs and gyms in Catalonia have reopened their doors once for a second time, following a successful legal battle against the local .... more>>
Wales is back in business - gyms, pools and leisure centres reopen their doors
Wales is back in business - gyms, pools and leisure centres reopen their doors   11 Aug 2020

Health clubs, gyms, indoor pools and leisure centres have reopened in Wales – nearly five months after being forced to close as part of the nationwide .... more>>
Wasps rugby club installs heat camera to ensure safe return to training
Wasps rugby club installs heat camera to ensure safe return to training   11 Aug 2020

English Premiership rugby club Wasps has installed a heat camera at its Broadstreet training facility near Coventry, as part of efforts to help .... more>>
Company profile


Painting With Light

By combining lighting, video, scenic and architectural elements, sound and special effects we tell stories, create emotion and give your audience an experience that they will always remember.

View full profile>>

Catalogue gallery


Featured Supplier

ResortSuite’s app lets guests control their own wellness itinerary

ResortSuite’s app lets guests control their own wellness itinerary

“The future has always been tech-based, but COVID-19 will drive this trend from a nice-to- have to a must-have,” claims Frank Pitsikalis, founder and CEO of hospitality management software system ResortSuite. More>>




in this issue

• Gyms on the high street – it's a go!
• JD Gyms buys Xercise4Less out of administration
• Family operator, GetSetGo! reveals launch plans



Latest jobs

Jobs Search



Membership Experience Team Member
Salary: Competitive
Location: Rugby, UK
Company: Xercise4Less
General Manager
Salary: £30K Basic circa
Location: Leeds, UK
Company: Coach Gyms
Reception – Bar Staff
Salary: Competitive
Location: Leeds, UK
Company: Coach Gyms
Diary dates
Powered by leisurediary.com

13-15 Aug 2020

FIBO China

National Exhibition and Convention Centre, Shanghai, China



Leisure Management magazine 2018 issue 1
Leisure Management
2018 issue 1

View issue contents
View on turning pages
Download PDF
  Interview: Katy Bowman
In her latest book, the biomechanist and author explains why we need to widen our spectrum of movement and connect with our inner hunter-gatherer More>>
  Tourism: High flyers
How bmi and Projekt Spielberg are growing British tourism to Graz More>>


Leisure Management magazine 2016 issue 1

Leisure Management
2016 issue 1

View issue contents
View turning pages
Download PDF
  Adult play: Making a big play
LM reports on the emerging trend of adults playing like kids More>>
  Gymtopia: Angels’ advocate
Gymtopia founder Ray Algar on making a difference beyond the health club walls More>>


Published by The Leisure Media Company Ltd Portmill House, Portmill Lane, Hitchin, Herts SG5 1DJ. Tel: +44 (0)1462 431385 | Contact us | About us | © Cybertrek Ltd